Sold! An Annual Snapshot of High-End Real Estate Sales

May 2022—Who doesn’t love a look inside the highest priced homes in our magnificent town? From single family homes to condos to country club communities, we’re showcasing the Top 5 highest sales in Sarasota and Manatee counties. Curiosity fulfilled!

Based on MLS reported sales for the 12-month period from April 4, 2021 through April 4, 2022

Top 5 Single Family Home Sales Sarasota County

Listing Agents (first) and Selling Agents included

171 S Washington Dr
$10,060,00—12/29/21
Bruce Myer, Coldwell Banker Realty
Alexis Smith-Frady, Compass Florida

1313 Westway Dr
$11,500,000—03/07/22
Listing & Selling Agent: 
Roger Pettingell, Coldwell Banker Realty

4300 Higel Ave
$12,000,000—10/15/21
Listing & Selling Agent: 
Mark Coppens, Living Vogue

7712, 7711 & 7760 Sanderling Rd
$14,000,000­—12/09/21
Donna-Wright Morgan, 
Coldwell Banker Sunstar Realty
Darla Fairchild, Coldwell Banker Realty

1900 Casey Key Rd
$16,500,000—04/28/21
Joel Schemmel, Premier Sotheby’s Intl Realty
Jennifer Linehan, Michael Saunders & Co

Top 5 Single Family Homes Manatee County

Listing Agents (first) and Selling Agents included

5050 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK
$9,100,000­—07/22/21
Alan Atchley, Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate
Judie Berger, Premier Sotheby’s Intl Realty

6600 Bayou Hammock Rd, LBK
$9,750,000—04/20/21
Bill Anderson & Mark Baron, 
Michael Saunders & Co
JoDene Moneuse, Michael Saunders & Co

5965 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK
$10,150,000—06/01/21
Roger Pettingell, Coldwell Banker Realty
Joel Schemmel, Premier Sotheby’s Intl Realty

6211 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK
$10,400,000—02/07/22
Donna-Wright Morgan, 
Listing & Selling Agent:  
Judy Kepecz-Hays, Coldwell Banker Realty

100 Beach Ave, Anna Maria
$16,000,000—02/02/22
Charles Buky, Coldwell Banker Realty
Lisa Morris, Premier Sotheby’s Intl Realty

Top 5 Condo Sales Sarasota County

Listing Agents (first) and Selling Agents included

Ritz-Carlton Residences, Sarasota
Quay Commons PH 1801
$7,908,600—04/20/2021
Julia DeCastro & Perry Corneau, Michael Saunders & Co
Roger Pettingell, Coldwell Banker Residential Realty

Ritz-Carlton Residences, Sarasota 
Quay Commons PH 1903 
$8,927,943—04/12/2021
Listing & Selling Agents:
Julia DeCastro & Perry Corneau, Michael Saunders & Co

EPOCH, Sarasota
605 S Gulfstream #12
$9,700,000—01/22/2022
Dianne Anderson, RE/MAX Platinum Realty
Adam Cuffaro, Michael Saunders & Co

EPOCH, Sarasota
605 S Gulfstream PH 18
$9,747,250—05/13/2021
Listing & Selling Agent: 
Amy Drake, Property Perspectives Group

Ritz-Carlton Residences, Sarasota 
Quay Commons PH 1903
$10,575,000—02/11/2022
Nora Johnson & Klaus Lang, Michael Saunders & Co
Beth Afflebach & Joan Dickinson, Michael Saunders & Co

Top 5 Condo Sales Manatee County

Listing Agents (first) and Selling Agents included

5622 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach
Vista Grande
$2,700,000—06/11/2021
Jen Sekel, Anna Maria Island Beaches Realty
Don Purvis, Beach House Real Estate

4985 Gulf of Mexico Dr #403
Positano
$3,495,000—04/09/2021
Reid Murphy, Developers Realty
Shelbi Loftin, Fine Properties

101 67th St, #1, Holmes Beach
West Wind Shores
$3,750,000—10/07/2021
Jennifer Chatt & Gail Tutewiler, Island Real Estate
Don Purvis, Beach House Real Estate

4965 Gulf of Mexico Dr #202
Positano
$3,875,000—01/27/2022
Listing: Non-Member Agent
Selling: Meghan Leiter, Michael Saunders & Co

4955 Gulf of Mexico Dr #101
Positano
$4,100,000—12/06/2021
Listing & Selling Agent: 
Reid Murphy, Developers Realty

Top 5 Sales Country Club Communities Sarasota County

Listing Agents (first) and Selling Agents included

3727 Caledonia Ln—Founders Club
$2,500,000—12/09/2021
Melissa Dovey, Founders Club Realty
Toni Zarghami, Keller Williams Classic Group

3129 Founders Club Dr—Founders Club
$2,575,000—11/15/2021
Kathy Callahan, Michael Saunders & Co
Judie Berger, Premier Sotheby’s Intl Realty

669 Trenton Way—The Oaks Clubside
$2,900,000—03/21/2022
Steve Abbe, Coldwell Banker Realty
Monica Verinder, Coldwell Banker Realty

144 Osprey Point Dr—The Oaks Bayside
$3,000,000—01/19/2022
Rachel Benderson, Michael Saunders & Co
Steve Abbe, Coldwell Banker Realty

8263 Archers Ct—Founders Club
$3,500,000—07/16/2021
Kathy Callahan, Michael Saunders & Co
Helen Jaquith, RE/MAX Platinum Realty

Top 5 Sales Country Club Communities Manatee County

Listing Agents (first) and Selling Agents included

8341 Lindrick Ln—The Concession Golf Club
$3,600,000—10/29/2021
Sara Boudarga & Nancie Kalin, Michael Saunders & Co
Laura Stavola, Premier Sotheby’s Intl Realty

8595 Lindrick Ln—The Concession Golf Club
$3,600,000—09/24/2021
Stacy Haas, Michael Saunders & Co
Andree Huffine, Coldwell Banker Realty

8415 Broadstone Ct—The Concession Golf Club
$3,800,000—02/28/2022
Stacy Haas, Michael Saunders & Co
Victoria Campbell, EXP Realty

8439 Lindrick Ln—The Concession Golf Club
$4,250,000—04/26/2021
Kim Ogilvie, Michael Saunders & Co
Mark Coppens, Living Vogue

8499 Lindrick Ln—The Concession Golf Club
$7,980,000—02/01/2022
Stacy Haas, Michael Saunders & Co
Ryan Skrzypkowski, Coldwell Banker Realty

Office Market Share Report

Ranked by Total Volume. Based on MLS data for the 12-month period March 13, 2021 to March 14, 2022

• COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, Sarasota
• PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, Downtown Sarasota
• MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, Downtown Sarasota
• KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER, Bradenton 
• FINE PROPERTIES, Sarasota
• RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP, Bradenton
• COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, Longboat Key
• BRIGHT REALTY, Sarasota
• MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, Siesta Key
• COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, Lakewood Ranch

Agent Market Share

Ranked by Total Volume. Based on MLS data for the 12-month period March 13, 2021 to March 14, 2022

• Jessica Adair, Locals Realty
• Roger Pettingell, Coldwell Banker Realty
• Jason Sato, Sato Real Estate
• Amy Drake, Property Perspectives Group
• Joel Schemmel, Schemmel Property Group, Premier Sotheby’s Int’l Realty
• Judy Kepecz-Hays, Coldwell Banker Realty
• Reid Murphy, Developers Realty
• Toni Zarghami, Zarghami Group, Keller Williams Classic Group
• Bruce Myer, Coldwell Banker Realty
• Curt Ware, The Ware Group, Keller Williams Classic Group